I would like to sell a nice solid set of rear fenders for 17-23 roadster or touring plus a set of splash aprons and I would like to get an idea of a fair asking price. Here are the fenders installed on my 15 roadster
I'm asking $150 each for similar fenders and I recently sold a decent pair of splash aprons, in primer, for $100. I hope this helps.
When I sold mine, I prices them relative to new ones from Rootlieb taking into consideration that the fender brackets were already riveted on.