Seeking opinions on early Holley carb comparisons 1912-1913 era
Posted: Sat Jun 12, 2021 10:50 am
Hello all, many of you know of my early 1913 Canadian Ford built in Sept/October of 1912.
For many years it had the incorrect carb on it (NH) and I've made it a fun project to put the car back to as all original & authentic as possible. I started out thinking that the car should have a Holly "two screw" type S carb. I used this carb for about two years. I have all the correct tools and fixtures to make this carb work very reliably with no leaks or issues. My abilities as a millwright and machinist have allowed me to make changes on many of these early carbs so they now have viton needle valves, and modern floats, and do NOT leak gas at all, but that's not the focus here. I've successfully rebuilt dozens of Holley carbs: G's, S's, NH's..... This year, the Holley S carb seems to be out of adjustment. My car would be very difficult to start, especially cold, and more often then not, when hot. Once running, it's performance was quite fine though. One really odd thing was with this Holley S, you would NEVER, EVER choke the engine to start it, EVER! Unless you really enjoy cranking! I have not investigated why it's misbehaving yet, but I will, and I will report back at some future time.
Further study and research has led me to believe that a more "period correct" carb would be the Holley H-1, the 3rd variation with no hot air clamp. I restored, and calibrated one I had, and installed it two weeks ago. Night and day difference.
I find this carb behaves more like a 1915 T I owned (with a correct period Holley G) a few years ago. Typical choke, and crank: 2 quarter cranks with choke on, then crank, and go. Or from a dormant state of about a week: 3-4 quarter cranks with choke on, ignition off, turn battery on, and instant start 9 times out of 10.
The Holley H-1 seems to have more get up and go, and the car seems to want to run better with considerably more pep. Easy starting, hot or cold, and lots of free starts.
Does anyone have any thoughts similar or different from my own comparisons? I'm interested in hearing what you have to say.
Just for the record, my ignition system is completely rebuilt with newly rebuilt Heinze coils (new windings & caps) calibrated to the best of my ability on a Strobo-Spark (John Reagan unit with my specially made adapter to accept the Heinze coils), Anderson timer, new wiring, good Champion X plugs, etc....
I will also note the the biggest interior design difference that I've noticed between the Holley S and H-1 is that the S has a spun sheet metal brass venturi, and the H-1 has the (identical to the G's) aluminum intricately shaped venturi.
In conclusion, it seems that the H-1 which is built pretty much like the later G's, very well built and great performance.
One last thing, I hope this is not considered out of place, but I am curious if anyone knows exactly what changes the late Stan Howe made to Holley H-1's to make the floats and needles work safely and reliably. I have made some of my own changes and when my car sits for about a week, I can smell the slightest hint of fuel. The needle has a very very small leak. Something I do NOT like, and have never had with other carbs. I would appreciate any info regarding what Mr. Howe did if that's not out of place. I respectfully admired all of his work and he was a true gentleman, but never had the opportunity to discuss the matter with him. RIP Stan.
For many years it had the incorrect carb on it (NH) and I've made it a fun project to put the car back to as all original & authentic as possible. I started out thinking that the car should have a Holly "two screw" type S carb. I used this carb for about two years. I have all the correct tools and fixtures to make this carb work very reliably with no leaks or issues. My abilities as a millwright and machinist have allowed me to make changes on many of these early carbs so they now have viton needle valves, and modern floats, and do NOT leak gas at all, but that's not the focus here. I've successfully rebuilt dozens of Holley carbs: G's, S's, NH's..... This year, the Holley S carb seems to be out of adjustment. My car would be very difficult to start, especially cold, and more often then not, when hot. Once running, it's performance was quite fine though. One really odd thing was with this Holley S, you would NEVER, EVER choke the engine to start it, EVER! Unless you really enjoy cranking! I have not investigated why it's misbehaving yet, but I will, and I will report back at some future time.
Further study and research has led me to believe that a more "period correct" carb would be the Holley H-1, the 3rd variation with no hot air clamp. I restored, and calibrated one I had, and installed it two weeks ago. Night and day difference.
I find this carb behaves more like a 1915 T I owned (with a correct period Holley G) a few years ago. Typical choke, and crank: 2 quarter cranks with choke on, then crank, and go. Or from a dormant state of about a week: 3-4 quarter cranks with choke on, ignition off, turn battery on, and instant start 9 times out of 10.
The Holley H-1 seems to have more get up and go, and the car seems to want to run better with considerably more pep. Easy starting, hot or cold, and lots of free starts.
Does anyone have any thoughts similar or different from my own comparisons? I'm interested in hearing what you have to say.
Just for the record, my ignition system is completely rebuilt with newly rebuilt Heinze coils (new windings & caps) calibrated to the best of my ability on a Strobo-Spark (John Reagan unit with my specially made adapter to accept the Heinze coils), Anderson timer, new wiring, good Champion X plugs, etc....
I will also note the the biggest interior design difference that I've noticed between the Holley S and H-1 is that the S has a spun sheet metal brass venturi, and the H-1 has the (identical to the G's) aluminum intricately shaped venturi.
In conclusion, it seems that the H-1 which is built pretty much like the later G's, very well built and great performance.
One last thing, I hope this is not considered out of place, but I am curious if anyone knows exactly what changes the late Stan Howe made to Holley H-1's to make the floats and needles work safely and reliably. I have made some of my own changes and when my car sits for about a week, I can smell the slightest hint of fuel. The needle has a very very small leak. Something I do NOT like, and have never had with other carbs. I would appreciate any info regarding what Mr. Howe did if that's not out of place. I respectfully admired all of his work and he was a true gentleman, but never had the opportunity to discuss the matter with him. RIP Stan.